AT&T's 'fiber-powered' crusade expands to Comcast
1 day ago / Read about 12 minute
Source:Light Reading
Escalating its fight with cable, AT&T sues Comcast for marketing HFC broadband as 'fiber-powered,' alleging the term deceives customers. AT&T filed a similar suit against Charter/Spectrum in late August.


(Source: Panther Media GmbH/Alamy Stock Photo)

AT&T isn't done picking fights with cable operators.

After suing Charter/Spectrum in August, AT&T has hit Comcast with a nearly identical lawsuit accusing the cable company of false advertising and unfair competition for using the term "fiber-powered" in ads and marketing materials that describe its hybrid fiber/coax (HFC) network and how HFC feeds Comcast's Wi-Fi platform.

"This case challenges Comcast's false advertising campaign for its residential internet service, marketed under the Xfinity brand to consumers nationwide. At the center of that campaign is Comcast's claim that Xfinity Internet and its associated WiFi service are 'Fiber-Powered'," AT&T stated in a suit filed November 13 with the US District Court for the Northern District of California.

As it argued in its Charter/Spectrum lawsuit, AT&T claimed that Comcast's advertising falsely suggests that its "fiber-powered" HFC and Wi-Fi connections are delivered entirely over fiber-optic cable.

Comcast has been asked for comment.

How the courts rule in these cases could have a significant impact on how cable operators market and sell broadband services delivered via HFC or how they even describe those network architectures in general. Success for AT&T in either case could embolden it or other fiber service providers to file similar lawsuits.

AT&T's attacks are focused on how cable operators describe HFC – an architecture that runs fiber to the node and connects homes to the node via coax – to consumers. Notably, new distributed access architecture (DAA) deployments also enable cable operators to deploy fiber-to-the-premises (FTTP) off the node on a targeted basis.

Comcast using 'sleight-of-hand'

AT&T claims that Comcast's ads and materials using "fiber" is a "sleight-of-hand" to describe its HFC network. The complaint points to multiple examples where Comcast uses "fiber-powered" to describe its residential Internet service architectures – including both fiber-to-the-home and fiber-to-the-node – and in small print noting that "Xfinity Internet is powered by fiber and connected to premises by coaxial cable."

"Comcast knows that the difference matters to consumers and is aiming to mislead them," AT&T claimed.

AT&T even appears to have an issue with Comcast's use of "coaxial cable," holding that using that label rather than "copper" in such disclosures is also "misleading to consumers" who are "unlikely to know that 'coaxial cable' is a copper-based connection."

AT&T's suit against Comcast seeks a permanent injunction, for Comcast to account for gains and profits from its alleged false advertising, for "enhanced damages," and a typical ask for Comcast to cover AT&T's costs for attorneys' fees and expenses. The lawsuit does not call out any specific dollar amounts.

AT&T is fixating on fiber

AT&T's complaints against Comcast and Spectrum come amid increasingly heated broadband competition and as AT&T leans hard into a plan to bring fiber to 60 million locations by 2030 via builds in its legacy wireline footprint and in other markets through a blend of partnerships and joint ventures. AT&T is also using fixed wireless access (FWA) to deliver residential broadband, but its strategy largely focuses on fiber.

Comcast and Spectrum, meanwhile, are both in the midst of HFC network upgrades alongside the use of FTTP in new and adjacent markets and in government-subsidized rural areas.

AT&T-Charter case heads to next phase

AT&T filed a similar lawsuit against Charter/Spectrum in late August with a Texas district court. Charter countered with a motion to dismiss the case, arguing that there's nothing false or misleading about Spectrum's use of "fiber-powered" and "100% fiber" to describe its network architectures. The cable operator also argued that a "reasonable customer" would understand the difference and that it's not plausible, despite AT&T's claims, that its use of "fiber-powered" would be material to a consumer's purchasing decision.

"By failing to allege any facts that explain why reasonable consumers would conclude that 'fiber-powered' means 100% fiber, AT&T has not given the Court a basis to make that same inferential leap," Charter told the court. "AT&T's lawsuit is based on a theory of falsity that makes no sense and is belied by its own factual allegations."

In a November 13 order that extended some filing deadlines, the Texas court said AT&T had until November 20 to file a reply to Charter's motion, and gave Charter until December 11 to file its responsive brief.