
Cable operators have plenty of options for keeping their hybrid fiber/coax (HFC) networks competitive. They can extend the life of DOCSIS 3.1 with DOCSIS 3.1+, make a move to DOCSIS 4.0 or go beyond it as tech develops to drive spectrum to 3GHz or even 6GHz. Or, they can just bite the bullet and go with PON in their most competitive markets.
Sticking with DOCSIS, the next step is DOCSIS 4.0 Optional Annex, which envisions a move to 3GHz (up from today's 1.8GHz state-of-the-art) and speeds of 25 Gbit/s. But will a push in that direction be worth it as PON technology races toward 50-Gig and beyond?
Whether cable can justify the time and cost to make those moves was a question raised by Jeff Heynen, VP of broadband access and home networking at Dell'Oro Group, in a recent blog post. He expands on that and other cable tech topics – including broadband equipment spending trends and the pressures being exerted on customer premises equipment (CPE) companies – in this episode of the Signal Strength Podcast.
While D4.0 Optional Annex is poised to extend the life of hybrid fiber/coax (HFC) networks, Heynen wonders whether the economics will ultimately pencil out.
But the technology is in its infancy. "Let's be honest. We're in the very early stages. We've got a long way to go," Heynen explained.
And getting there will require some difficult decisions about the outside plant, including whether to increase power levels at existing amplifiers or add more active electronics to the network.
Catching up with PON
A larger concern is timing. Heynen doesn't expect 3GHz technology to reach commercial networks until sometime beyond 2030. By then, fiber operators could already be well down the road with 50G PON.
"50-Gig PON is starting to get deployed now – not so much in the Western markets, but certainly in China. By the end of this decade … operators that will have already deployed at least 50-Gig-capable line cards and platforms and maybe they're putting in 10-Gig optics," Heynen explained. "If the goal of 3GHz is to get you to 25-Gig, is it worth it because you're already behind?"
That raises another possibility: Cable operators could aim higher for 6GHz and speeds of 50 Gbit/s.
Even before any of that enters the picture, the rollout of DOCSIS 4.0 is in the early stages, led by the work underway at operators such as Comcast, Charter Communications/Spectrum and Mediacom Communications. Many others are focused on DOCSIS 3.1 mid-split and high-split upgrades that enhance upstream speeds, and DOCSIS 3.1+, which provides a downstream boost by opening up additional OFDM channels.
Heynen believes financial pressures could ultimately persuade additional operators to embrace DOCSIS 4.0 rather than pursue more expensive PON overbuilds. But the real test won't be how much speed those upgrades deliver. It will be whether they help cable operators gain and retain broadband customers, Heynen said.
If DOCSIS upgrades fuel stronger subscriber growth, operators will have a stronger argument for continuing down the HFC path. If not, fiber overbuilds could become more attractive despite their higher costs, he noted.
CPE suppliers challenged on multiple fronts
Meanwhile, the outlook is challenging for cable modem and gateway suppliers that are grappling with myriad issues, including cable broadband subscriber losses, the timing of DOCSIS upgrades, surging memory prices and the FCC's ban on new foreign-made consumer routers.
"They're all being squeezed on the component side. And it's not just memory. It's capacitors. It's screws. It's everything," Heynen said.
There's been a shift in the CPE model as more operators buy direct from original design manufacturers (ODMs) that have their own manufacturing, which in turn puts pressure on original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) that don't have that capability.
But there's still room in the market for OEMs that can manage software integration and supply chains – areas where some operators don't have the in-house expertise or background to handle – Heynen points out.
Despite those challenges, Heynen remains relatively upbeat about the broadband equipment market, despite some recent lumpiness and the pushing out of spending by certain cable operators. Dell'Oro expects cable's current investment cycle to continue through at least 2028.
Here's a snapshot of the discussion:
Heynen expands on why he questions whether a future push to 3GHz technology is the right move as PON heads toward 50-Gig and beyond (04:00)
How a move to 3GHz (and possibly 6GHz) creates significant challenges with respect to amplifier spacing and network power levels (06:10)
Where cable operators are focusing their HFC upgrades today, including spectrum splits and DOCSIS 4.0, and whether the time is right for cable operators to overbuild with PON (11:00)
Why and how reliability is becoming as important (or perhaps more important) than speeds and feeds (16:00)
How cable broadband subscriber trends, rising memory costs and FCC policies are putting stress on CPE suppliers (20:00)
How Prpl is gaining traction with CPE manufacturers as a device management and analytics platform and becoming a stronger competitor to platforms such as RDK (26:30)
Heynen on how cable tech companies fared during this round of earnings and an update on his long-term forecast for the sector (30:00)
How the emergence of low-Earth orbit satellite broadband is altering the competitive landscape for broadband (36:00)
